%PDF-1.4
%
1 0 obj
<<
/Type /Catalog
/Metadata 2 0 R
/Pages 3 0 R
>>
endobj
4 0 obj
<<
/Creator (eCopy, Inc)
/Producer (eCopy, Inc)
/ModDate (03-14-2011)
/Author (s5l)
/CreationDate (03-14-2011)
>>
endobj
2 0 obj
<<
/Type /Metadata
/Subtype /XML
/Length 5 0 R
>>
stream
application/pdf
s5l
eCopy, Inc
2011-03-14T18:23:07-07:00
2011-03-14T18:23:07-07:00
2011-03-14T18:23:07-07:00
eCopy, Inc
uuid:f016aad0-b8dc-4581-b86d-ffa38a3460a5
uuid:94714455-51af-4d7e-866f-8603a11277c2
endstream
endobj
3 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 19
/Kids [6 0 R 7 0 R 8 0 R 9 0 R 10 0 R 11 0 R 12 0 R 13 0 R 14 0 R 15 0 R
16 0 R 17 0 R 18 0 R 19 0 R 20 0 R 21 0 R 22 0 R 23 0 R 24 0 R]
>>
endobj
5 0 obj
3534
endobj
6 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [25 0 R 26 0 R 27 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 28 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
7 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [29 0 R 30 0 R 31 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 32 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
8 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [33 0 R 34 0 R 35 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 36 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
9 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [37 0 R 38 0 R 39 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 40 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
10 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [41 0 R 42 0 R 43 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 44 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
11 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [45 0 R 46 0 R 47 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 48 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
12 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [49 0 R 50 0 R 51 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 52 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
13 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [53 0 R 54 0 R 55 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 56 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
14 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [57 0 R 58 0 R 59 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 60 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
15 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [61 0 R 62 0 R 63 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 64 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
16 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [65 0 R 66 0 R 67 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 68 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
17 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [69 0 R 70 0 R 71 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 72 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
18 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [73 0 R 74 0 R 75 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 76 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
19 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [77 0 R 78 0 R 79 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 80 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
20 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [81 0 R 82 0 R 83 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 84 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
21 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [85 0 R 86 0 R 87 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 88 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
22 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [89 0 R 90 0 R 91 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 92 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
23 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [93 0 R 94 0 R 95 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 96 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
24 0 obj
<<
/Parent 3 0 R
/Contents [97 0 R 98 0 R 99 0 R]
/Type /Page
/Resources 100 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/eCpyResolution 300
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
25 0 obj
<<
/Length 101 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
26 0 obj
<<
/Length 102 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im7 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F8 34.42 Tf
100 Tz
219.84 593.04 TD
(EXHIBIT 1) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
27 0 obj
<<
/Length 103 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x%Ƚ0Fwԡoihp5q
vJQqp s?B+dQϔI|ṣ9 l=Uyo2`c%bjbW٩TJ
endstream
endobj
28 0 obj
<<
/XObject 104 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 105 0 R
>>
endobj
29 0 obj
<<
/Length 106 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
30 0 obj
<<
/Length 107 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im12 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F13 12.69 Tf
100 Tz
54.96 725.04 TD
(1 KILPATRICK TOWNSEND & STOCKTON LLP) Tj
/F14 11.98 Tf
25.20 -11.52 TD
(JAMES G. GILLILAND, JR. \(State Bar No.1 07988\)) Tj
/F14 12.79 Tf
-26.40 -12.48 TD
(2 TIMOTHY R. CAHN \(State Bar No. 162136\)) Tj
/F14 11.96 Tf
26.88 -11.52 TD
(MEHRNAZ BOROUMAND SMITH \(State Bar No. 197271\)) Tj
/F14 12.76 Tf
-26.40 -12.72 TD
(3 HOLLY GAUDREAU \(State Bar No. 209114\)) Tj
/F14 11.95 Tf
26.40 -11.28 TD
(RYAN BRICKER \(State Bar No. 269100\)) Tj
/F14 12.94 Tf
-27.12 -12.72 TD
(4 Two Embarcadero Center Eighth Floor) Tj
/F15 13.43 Tf
26.64 -11.52 TD
(San Francisco, CA 94111) Tj
/F13 10.77 Tf
-26.16 -12.48 TD
(5 Telephone: \(415\) 576-0200) Tj
/F15 13.30 Tf
26.64 -11.52 TD
(Facsimile: \(415\) 576-0300) Tj
/F13 9.56 Tf
-26.88 -12.48 TD
(6 Email: jgilliland~kilpatricktownsend.com) Tj
/F15 13.11 Tf
62.40 -11.52 TD
(tcahn~kilpatricktownsend. com) Tj
/F13 12.81 Tf
-62.40 -12.48 TD
(7 mboroumand~kilpatricktownsend.com) Tj
/F15 12.99 Tf
63.12 -11.28 TD
(hgaud reau~kilpatricktownsend. com) Tj
/F13 12.02 Tf
-62.88 -12.72 TD
(8 rbricker~kilpatricktownsend.com) Tj
/F14 13.65 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(9 Attorneys for Plaintiff) Tj
/F14 12.00 Tf
26.16 -11.52 TD
(SONY COMPUTER ENTERTAINMENT AMERICA LLC) Tj
/F15 11.76 Tf
-32.40 -12.48 TD
(10) Tj
/F15 10.08 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(11) Tj
/F15 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(12) Tj
/F15 11.52 Tf
0.24 -23.76 TD
(13) Tj
/F14 11.99 Tf
181.92 48.24 TD
(UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT) Tj
/F14 11.98 Tf
-39.12 -23.76 TD
(FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA) Tj
/F14 11.94 Tf
61.44 -24.00 TD
(SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION) Tj
/F13 13.55 Tf
-204.24 -24.48 TD
(14 SONY COMPUTER ENTERTAINMENT) Tj
/F14 11.99 Tf
31.44 -11.28 TD
(AMERICA LLC,) Tj
/F14 11.89 Tf
250.32 12.00 TD
(Case No. 11-cv-00167 SI) Tj
/F15 11.52 Tf
-281.76 -24.72 TD
(15) Tj
0.00 -23.76 TD
(16) Tj
0.00 -24.00 TD
(17) Tj
/F15 11.57 Tf
105.12 36.48 TD
(Plaintiff,) Tj
/F14 11.89 Tf
176.88 9.60 TD
(\(PROPOSED\) ORDER RE) Tj
/F14 12.01 Tf
-.24 -9.60 TD
(MARCH 10, 2011 TELEPHONIC) Tj
/F15 12.49 Tf
0.24 -12.00 TD
(HEARING RE JOINT LETTER ON) Tj
/F14 12.02 Tf
0.00 -11.76 TD
(IMPOUNDMENT ISSUES AND JOINT) Tj
/F14 11.98 Tf
0.00 -12.00 TD
(LETTER ON DISCOVERY) Tj
/F15 10.56 Tf
-213.60 12.00 TD
(v.) Tj
/F14 11.99 Tf
-36.24 -24.24 TD
(GEORGE HOTZ; HECTOR MARTIN) Tj
/F13 12.37 Tf
-32.16 -12.48 TD
(18 CANTERO; SVEN PETER; and DOES) Tj
/F13 9.03 Tf
32.88 -11.28 TD
(1 through 100,) Tj
/F15 11.52 Tf
-32.88 -12.72 TD
(19) Tj
/F15 12.48 Tf
-.96 -24.00 TD
(20) Tj
/F15 11.04 Tf
0.00 -24.24 TD
(21) Tj
/F15 12.48 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(22) Tj
/F14 13.47 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(23 On March 10,2011, the Court held a hearing on the parties' February 18, 2011 and) Tj
/F15 13.09 Tf
106.08 84.96 TD
(Defendants.) Tj
/F14 12.43 Tf
-105.84 -109.20 TD
(24 February 28, 2011 joint letters \(Docket Nos. 85 and 86\) on discovery and impoundment) Tj
/F13 9.31 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(25 disputes. Having considered all the papers and arguments, the Court enters the following) Tj
/F14 15.83 Tf
0.00 -24.24 TD
(26 order:) Tj
/F13 10.06 Tf
0.00 -24.24 TD
(27 \(1\) Plaintiff SCEA is authorized to serve third party PayPal, Inc. with a subpoena) Tj
/F14 12.40 Tf
0.24 -24.24 TD
(28 seeking the following limited information relating to personal jurisdiction: documents sufficient) Tj
/F14 8.09 Tf
33.12 -31.20 TD
(\(PROPOSEDj ORDER RE MARCH 10,2011 TELEPHONIC HEARING) Tj
/F15 8.58 Tf
0.00 -11.28 TD
(CASE NO. 11-cv-00167 SI) Tj
/F13 6.24 Tf
454.56 11.76 TD
(- 1 -) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
31 0 obj
<<
/Length 108 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x%Ƚ0>7Pۯ440I+B0 8ZnVqp @C;!KϕyNGJҴoh{ }M,
c:2Xcb٪xL
endstream
endobj
32 0 obj
<<
/XObject 109 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 110 0 R
>>
endobj
33 0 obj
<<
/Length 111 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
34 0 obj
<<
/Length 112 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im19 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F20 8.87 Tf
100 Tz
54.72 724.56 TD
(1 to identify the source of funds in California that went into any PayPal account associated with) Tj
/F21 13.82 Tf
-.72 -24.00 TD
(2 geohot~gmail.com for the period of January 1, 2009 to February 1, 2011. SCEA is ordered) Tj
/F20 9.00 Tf
0.24 -24.24 TD
(3 to redraft its subpoena to seek this information. SCEA is further ordered to inform PayPal,) Tj
/F21 13.86 Tf
-.48 -24.00 TD
(4 Inc. and other subpoenaed parties that any information produced in response to the) Tj
/F22 12.37 Tf
0.48 -24.00 TD
(5 subpoena shall be provided on an Attorneys' Eyes Only basis and that the issuance of the) Tj
/F22 12.39 Tf
-.24 -24.00 TD
(6 subpoena is without prejudice to its right to file a Motion to Quash. \(See Docket No. 92\)) Tj
/F21 11.52 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(7) Tj
/F21 11.53 Tf
62.64 -1.44 TD
(\(2\)) Tj
/F22 11.95 Tf
36.24 2.40 TD
(Mr. Hotz is ordered to sign a consent for SCEA to obtain his Twitter posts from) Tj
/F21 14.70 Tf
-98.64 -24.96 TD
(8 January 1, 2009 to the present.) Tj
/F21 11.04 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(9) Tj
/F21 11.53 Tf
62.64 -1.44 TD
(\(3\)) Tj
/F22 11.95 Tf
36.24 2.40 TD
(Defendant George Hotz is ordered to appear in California for a deposition) Tj
/F22 12.43 Tf
-104.64 -24.96 TD
(10 relating solely to the question of personal jurisdiction. SCEA shall pay reasonable expenses) Tj
/F22 12.49 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(11 of Mr. Hotz to be deposed in California. The parties shall determine the date of the) Tj
/F22 12.45 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(12 deposition. Additionally, the parties have stipulated that Mr. Hotz cannot be served with) Tj
/F22 12.41 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(13 process by the parties to this action or the parties identified in SCEA's Certification of) Tj
/F22 12.36 Tf
0.00 -23.76 TD
(14 Interested Entities or Person \(Docket No. 16\) when he appears at his personal jurisdiction) Tj
/F22 13.22 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(15 deposition in California.) Tj
/F20 10.79 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(16 \(4\) With regard to the impoundment, the Court orders that:) Tj
/F21 11.52 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(17) Tj
0.00 -23.76 TD
(18) Tj
/F21 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(19) Tj
/F21 12.48 Tf
-.72 -24.00 TD
(20) Tj
/F21 11.04 Tf
0.00 -24.24 TD
(21) Tj
/F21 12.24 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(22) Tj
/F21 12.48 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(23) Tj
0.24 -24.24 TD
(24) Tj
0.00 -24.00 TD
(25) Tj
0.24 -24.24 TD
(26) Tj
0.00 -24.24 TD
(27) Tj
0.24 -24.24 TD
(28) Tj
/F22 11.95 Tf
86.16 263.76 TD
(\(a\) The Intelligence Group \("TIG"\), the third party neutral chosen by both parties,) Tj
/F22 11.98 Tf
18.00 -21.60 TD
(shall only take steps with regard to the impounded devices that are authorized by) Tj
/F21 12.82 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(Court order.) Tj
/F22 11.96 Tf
-17.76 -26.40 TD
(\(b\) The first $7000 of TIG costs will be split equally between SCEA and Mr. Hotz.) Tj
/F22 11.98 Tf
18.00 -21.60 TD
(SCEA has agreed to and shall pay any amount over the $7000.) Tj
/F22 12.00 Tf
-17.76 -26.40 TD
(\(c\) TIG is ordered to conduct the impoundment in the forensically sound manner as) Tj
18.00 -21.60 TD
(proposed in its Certification of February 27, 2011, including Exhibit A to that) Tj
/F22 12.10 Tf
0.00 -24.24 TD
(certification. Attached hereto as Exhibit 1 is a true and correct copy of the) Tj
/F22 11.95 Tf
0.48 -24.24 TD
(February 27, 2011 Certification and Exhibit A.) Tj
/F22 11.98 Tf
-18.00 -26.64 TD
(\(d\) Judge Illston's modified impoundment order requires the isolation, segregation) Tj
/F22 11.99 Tf
18.00 -21.60 TD
(and/or removal of information related to Defendant Hotz's circumvention of the) Tj
/F22 12.11 Tf
-.24 -24.24 TD
(technological protection measures in the PS3 System. The Court orders the) Tj
/F22 8.03 Tf
-72.00 -32.16 TD
(\(PROPOSEDj ORDER RE MARCH 10, 2011 TELEPHONIC HEARING) Tj
/F22 7.97 Tf
0.00 -11.28 TD
(CASE NO. 11-cv-00167 SI) Tj
/F22 10.66 Tf
454.32 13.20 TD
(- 2 -) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
35 0 obj
<<
/Length 113 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x%;0wԡmh`IW`Dq<d@{ _z.|D*t٪yP}X$sXOkg
vSs=FN
endstream
endobj
36 0 obj
<<
/XObject 114 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 115 0 R
>>
endobj
37 0 obj
<<
/Length 116 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
38 0 obj
<<
/Length 117 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im26 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F27 6.24 Tf
100 Tz
56.40 727.20 TD
(1) Tj
/F27 11.04 Tf
-.96 -24.24 TD
(2) Tj
/F27 10.56 Tf
0.24 -24.24 TD
(3) Tj
/F27 12.00 Tf
-.48 -24.00 TD
(4) Tj
/F27 11.04 Tf
0.48 -24.00 TD
(5) Tj
/F27 11.52 Tf
-.24 -24.00 TD
(6) Tj
/F28 11.94 Tf
98.40 120.96 TD
(parties and TIG to meet and confer regarding what exactly is information related) Tj
/F28 11.95 Tf
-.48 -24.00 TD
(to the circumvention of the technological protection measures in the PS3 System) Tj
/F28 12.06 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(and a procedure to isolate, segregate and remove such information. The parties) Tj
/F28 11.96 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(shall submit a description of the protocol to the Court for entry into an order by no) Tj
/F28 11.82 Tf
0.48 -24.00 TD
(later than March 28, 2011.) Tj
/F28 11.99 Tf
-.72 -24.00 TD
(With regard to jurisdictional discovery of the impounded devices, the Court) Tj
/F27 11.53 Tf
-35.52 -2.40 TD
(\(5\)) Tj
/F29 10.14 Tf
-62.16 -22.56 TD
(7 orders that:) Tj
/F29 10.37 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(8 \(a\) In order to avoid conducting discovery searches on original impounded devices) Tj
/F29 10.31 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(9 belonging to Mr. Hotz, TIG shall make an additional copy of both the encrypted and) Tj
/F28 14.03 Tf
-6.24 -24.00 TD
(10 unencrypted versions of the impounded hard drives and keep them in their) Tj
/F27 25.59 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(11 possession.) Tj
/F28 13.80 Tf
0.00 -23.76 TD
(12 \(b\) TIG shall then conduct a forensically sound search of the impounded devices to) Tj
/F28 13.84 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(13 determine whether: \(i\) they contain all or portions of the development tools for the) Tj
/F27 15.53 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(14 PlayStation 3 System and \(ii\) the impounded devices have been used to access or) Tj
/F28 13.93 Tf
0.24 -23.76 TD
(15 connect to the PlayStation Network. The Court orders the parties and TIG to meet) Tj
/F28 14.05 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(16 and confer on a protocol for TIG to perform these searches. The parties shall) Tj
/F28 13.87 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(17 submit a description of the protocol to the Court for entry into an order by no later) Tj
/F29 15.00 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(18 than March 16,2011.) Tj
/F27 11.28 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(19) Tj
/F27 11.53 Tf
68.16 -1.44 TD
(\(6\)) Tj
/F28 11.98 Tf
35.52 2.40 TD
(The parties shall enter a Stipulated Protective Order for all discovery matters.) Tj
/F27 13.83 Tf
-104.64 -24.96 TD
(20 To the extent the parties are unable to agree on the terms, they are ordered to file a joint) Tj
/F27 13.84 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(21 letter no longer than 10 pages to set forth the disputed terms and the parties' respective) Tj
/F28 14.62 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(22 positions.) Tj
/F27 12.48 Tf
0.00 -24.24 TD
(23) Tj
/F29 15.04 Tf
0.00 -24.00 TD
(24 IT IS SO ORDERED.) Tj
/F27 12.24 Tf
0.24 -24.24 TD
(25) Tj
/F27 11.59 Tf
33.36 -18.72 TD
(DATED:) Tj
/F27 12.48 Tf
-33.36 -5.52 TD
(26) Tj
/F27 12.24 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(27) Tj
/F27 12.48 Tf
0.00 -24.24 TD
(28) Tj
/F28 11.92 Tf
286.08 42.00 TD
(HON. JOSEPH C. SPERO) Tj
/F28 11.96 Tf
0.00 -12.24 TD
(UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE) Tj
/F27 12.74 Tf
-.48 -12.00 TD
(JUDGE) Tj
/F27 8.88 Tf
-252.72 -24.96 TD
(63207604 vi) Tj
/F28 8.00 Tf
0.24 -24.00 TD
(\(PROPOSEDj ORDER RE MARCH 10, 2011 TELEPHONIC HEARING) Tj
/F28 7.93 Tf
0.00 -11.04 TD
(CASE NO. 11-cv-00167 SI) Tj
/F27 11.38 Tf
454.08 12.48 TD
(- 3 -) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
39 0 obj
<<
/Length 118 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x%;0wԡmh`IW`Dq<d@{! _z.|D*t٪yP}X$sXOkg
vSs=FlP
endstream
endobj
40 0 obj
<<
/XObject 119 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 120 0 R
>>
endobj
41 0 obj
<<
/Length 121 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
42 0 obj
<<
/Length 122 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im33 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F34 22.09 Tf
100 Tz
243.84 664.08 TD
(EXHIBIT 1) Tj
/F34 7.47 Tf
-206.88 -256.80 TD
('\\) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
43 0 obj
<<
/Length 123 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x%Ƚ0>7PۯTM$`!?ϯTr1ubO} =\G MHي48<@96!ݞE0.8]Zblb٪TR
endstream
endobj
44 0 obj
<<
/XObject 124 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 125 0 R
>>
endobj
45 0 obj
<<
/Length 126 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
46 0 obj
<<
/Length 127 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im38 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F39 10.26 Tf
100 Tz
170.88 650.16 TD
(CERTIFICATION OIt' MICHAEL GREl'"NIER, C.FCE, EnCE) Tj
/F39 9.87 Tf
-66.48 -24.00 TD
(1 Michael Grennier, CFCE EnCE, of full age an duly sworn, does hereby state as follows:) Tj
/F40 9.67 Tf
32.64 -22.80 TD
(I . On Februar 26th, 2011, .I lOl'ardcd the certification per both parties reqiiest and) Tj
/F41 6.80 Tf
-31.92 -23.52 TD
(according to the conference calt of both parties held on Februry 251/', 2011. \(See attac11ed as) Tj
/F39 5.00 Tf
0.48 -22.80 TD
(Exhibit ) Tj
/F39 9.56 Tf
31.92 0.72 TD
(A\).) Tj
/F41 7.53 Tf
-1.20 -22.80 TD
(2. Steward Kellar, Es., Defense counsel representing Mr. George Hotz, agreed to) Tj
/F41 5.00 Tf
-30.72 -23.28 TD
(the process listed in ) Tj
/F40 9.28 Tf
85.68 1.20 TD
(the attached certification, as long as the bit-stream image of the drive was) Tj
/F39 10.20 Tf
-84.96 -23.04 TD
(wiped after the searching processes were completed. He would not agree. however to begin the) Tj
/F39 10.31 Tf
0.24 -22.32 TD
(process on Monday, February 28, 2011, where Mr. Hotz would provide unencrypted access to) Tj
/F40 9.33 Tf
0.48 -22.80 TD
(The Intellgence \('\)TOUP for purposes of creating an unencrypted bit-stream copy of his clients) Tj
/F41 5.00 Tf
0.00 -22.56 TD
(hard drives, believing that a motion would be ) Tj
189.12 2.16 TD
(fied in order for ) Tj
/F41 6.93 Tf
70.32 0.96 TD
(Plainti to maintain a preserved) Tj
/F39 10.28 Tf
-258.72 -25.92 TD
(copy for discovery purposes. Mr. Hotz clearly stated tbat his client would never agree to ANY) Tj
/F40 9.20 Tf
0.48 -22.08 TD
(copy being created, which could be .retaned for puroses other fuan the impoundment order and) Tj
/F40 9.25 Tf
0.00 -22.80 TD
(the processes mentioned in my fir.st certification.) Tj
/F41 5.00 Tf
30.72 -21.36 TD
(3. After sending my ) Tj
/F39 10.52 Tf
106.08 0.96 TD
(requested certification to both partes, i was advised that Mr.) Tj
/F41 7.20 Tf
-136.56 -24.00 TD
(Hot? will not agree to any hit-stram copies of the hard drives. It was further proposed by) Tj
/F39 10.80 Tf
0.00 -22.56 TD
(Defndants counsel that we use Mr. Hotz'g computer and operating system to conduct the) Tj
/F40 8.88 Tf
0.72 -23.04 TD
(seaches and securely delete the data.) Tj
/F41 7.30 Tf
30.72 -22.08 TD
(4. According to the Cyber Security Institute, Computer Forensics is defined at the) Tj
/F40 9.15 Tf
-30.24 -23.52 TD
(preservation, identiJ'ication, extraction, interpretation, and documentation of computer evidence,) Tj
/F41 6.62 Tf
0.48 -22.32 TD
(to include the rules of evidence, legal processes, integrity of evidence, factual reporting of the) Tj
/F41 7.47 Tf
0.48 -22.32 TD
(information tound, and providing expert opinion in a court of law or other legal and/or) Tj
/F40 9.23 Tf
0.24 -23.52 TD
(admistrative proceeding as to what W09 found. In hiisc terrmi, Computer lunmsics is a science) Tj
/F41 5.00 Tf
0.24 -40.80 TD
(Second Certification Sony ) Tj
/F40 10.36 Tf
111.36 0.96 TD
(V Hotz2l27 /2011) Tj
/F39 11.99 Tf
251.52 2.64 TD
(Pagel) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
47 0 obj
<<
/Length 128 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x%ȹ0}ŖP{c+\"D9JnTqp c?=tɪ~bAmcLא2~m'WX_.G-XN,J>`T
endstream
endobj
48 0 obj
<<
/XObject 129 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 130 0 R
>>
endobj
49 0 obj
<<
/Length 131 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
50 0 obj
<<
/Length 132 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im45 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F46 9.99 Tf
100 Tz
102.72 650.40 TD
(in which fai:l bai;ed results of an cxamim;rs findings should achieve the same result of any oih~r) Tj
/F46 10.54 Tf
0.48 -22.80 TD
(computer forensic examiner. The use of standards and controls in scientific experiments is a) Tj
/F46 10.05 Tf
0.72 -23.04 TD
(fundamental axiom ofthe scientific method. No experiment can be considered "scientific" unless) Tj
/F46 10.12 Tf
0.00 -23.76 TD
(they are used to ensure reliable results. An important consideration is the nature of the scientific) Tj
/F47 9.77 Tf
0.72 -22.56 TD
(experiment itself a'\) it may require the use of multiple stadards and controls. Likewise, this) Tj
/F48 7.27 Tf
0.24 -23.04 TD
(axiom holds true in forensic science. A scientific experiment is a controlled experiment.) Tj
/F47 9.74 Tf
0.72 -22.56 TD
(Variahles are intentionally introduced or changed one at a time and the results .monitored.) Tj
/F46 10.18 Tf
0.00 -22.80 TD
(Physical evidence is analyzed using methods and procedures that have previously been verified) Tj
/F47 9.42 Tf
0.72 -22.80 TD
(or valdated with the use of appropriate stadards and controls. Therefore, all forensic science) Tj
/F48 5.00 Tf
0.24 -22.80 TD
(disciplines must document in their methods and procedures specific ) Tj
/F47 9.09 Tf
274.08 3.60 TD
(stadards an.d controls. They) Tj
/F47 9.80 Tf
-273.84 -25.92 TD
(must be used when analyzing physical evidence as a memis to demonstrate that scientific) Tj
/F46 10.76 Tf
0.00 -22.08 TD
(principles and quality assuruce practices were followed. Their use wil also e;iisure that the) Tj
/F48 5.00 Tf
0.24 -23.76 TD
(methods, procedures, and instrumentation are f\\ctionig correctly, and that ) Tj
/F46 10.75 Tf
311.52 5.04 TD
(the results obtaied) Tj
/F47 9.28 Tf
-310.32 -27.12 TD
(are accurte, reliable, and repeatable. 1 For these reasns, we maintain a computer forensics lab) Tj
/F46 11.06 Tf
0.24 -22.56 TD
(where I test our hardware and softare to ensure that they are work properly and use only) Tj
/F46 10.20 Tf
0.48 -22.56 TD
(software and hardware which is known to me and my lab personnel. In order for TIG to isolate,) Tj
/F46 10.19 Tf
0.24 -22.56 TD
(segregate and/or remove the information on those devices related to Defendant's circumvention) Tj
/F46 10.00 Tf
0.24 -22.32 TD
(devices, I recommend these standard principles to be applied.) Tj
/F48 7.78 Tf
31.44 -22.56 TD
(5. BaSed upon the above explanations, it would be completely improper for The) Tj
/F48 5.00 Tf
-30.96 -24.00 TD
(Intelligence Group to lise a client's computer for anything other than ) Tj
/F47 9.38 Tf
282.24 4.32 TD
(makng a bit-stream image) Tj
/F46 5.00 Tf
-281.28 -26.40 TD
(of ) Tj
/F46 10.26 Tf
10.32 0.00 TD
(the hard drive. TIG's recommended procedures are:) Tj
/F48 5.00 Tf
-9.60 -36.24 TD
(1 ;rohnJ. Barbara _ Autlior. deneral Editor fbi the "Handbook of ) Tj
/F47 9.09 Tf
225.60 -.72 TD
(Digital & Multiedia IMdence".!!'!fuli.tL!?) Tj
/F46 7.57 Tf
-226.08 -13.92 TD
(J:f.lll!\)j!na Pr= in 2007Pu,ql1~ti~il.9ll.E\(\)ri"'3"iL' J...\('tm'il1~ \(lJ.t12:/.iwww.foi.ci\\skmali.cOi\\ - Coniputer POJ"enic!l) Tj
/F46 8.14 Tf
0.24 -8.40 TD
(S\\;indurds and Controls) Tj
/F47 9.63 Tf
0.00 -28.08 TD
(Second Certificati.oIl Sony V Hotz 2/27/2011) Tj
/F48 7.60 Tf
363.12 3.60 TD
(Page 2) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
51 0 obj
<<
/Length 133 0 R
/Filter /FlateDecode
>>
stream
x%;0wԡ4m`IW`Dq<d@{! _z.|@ :l