decoration decoration

When you want to know more...
For layout only
Site Map
About Groklaw
Legal Research
ApplevSamsung p.2
Cast: Lawyers
Comes v. MS
Gordon v MS
IV v. Google
Legal Docs
MS Litigations
News Picks
Novell v. MS
Novell-MS Deal
OOXML Appeals
Quote Database
Red Hat v SCO
Salus Book
SCEA v Hotz
SCO Appeals
SCO Bankruptcy
SCO Financials
SCO Overview
SCO v Novell
Sean Daly
Software Patents
Switch to Linux
Unix Books
Your contributions keep Groklaw going.
To donate to Groklaw 2.0:

Groklaw Gear

Click here to send an email to the editor of this weblog.

To read comments to this article, go here
SCO's 100-Day Notice to IBM - as text
Monday, April 04 2005 @ 01:24 AM EDT

Here's another oldie but goldie we somehow didn't get done in text, SCO's 100-day notice letter [PDF] sent to IBM regarding "termination" of IBM's AIX license back in March of 2003.

What is interesting to me is that it references all five of the agreements, including the one that clearly says that code IBM writes is theirs. The other interesting thing I note is that they terminated, according to them, primarily based on IBM allegedly failing to protect SCO's trade secrets. But SCO later dropped its trade secrets claim, very possibly because it is seriously doubtful that there are any trade secrets left in UNIX, and the contractual agreement specified that any trade secrets that became public knowledge were no longer under any contractual requirement of confidentiality. So, what's left?

The other thing I noticed is that in this letter, they don't claim ownership of copyrights.


Exhibit E



March 6, 2003

Mr. Sam Palmisano
Chief Executive Officer

Re: Software Agreement Number Soft-00015,
Sublicensing Agreement Number Sub-00015A
Substitution Agreement Number XFER-00015B
Side Letter dated February 1, 1985
Amendment X dated October 16, 1996

Dear Mr. Palmisano:

We are successors in interest to the above-referenced Agreements pursuant to that certain Asset Purchase Agreement by and between the Santa Cruz Operation, Inc. and Novell, Inc. dated as of September 19, 1995 (the "Asset Purchase Agreement"), having received under the Asset Purchase Agreement all rights and ownership of UNIX and UnixWare, including source code, source documentation, source listings and annotations, all rights pertaining to UNIX and UnixWare under any software development contracts, licenses and any other contracts which pertain to UNIX-related business, and including without limitation:

Software and Sublicensing Agreements - This includes the source code and sublicensing agreements that Seller has with its OEM End User and Educational customers. The total number of these agreements is approximately 30,000. [Schedule 1.1(a) to Asset Purchase Agreement, ¶III (L).]

We have rights to enforce any violation of our trade secrets by International Business Machines Corporation ("IBM"). These rights are secured by certain agreements between AT&T and IBM dated as of February 1, 1985, designated as Software Agreement Number Soft-00015, Sublicensing Agreement Number Sub-00015A, Substitution Agreement Number XFER-00015B, Side Letter dated February 1, 1985, and Amendment X dated October 16, 1996 (collectively the AT&T/IBM UNIX Agreements).

IBM is obligated under the AT&T/IBM UNIX Agreements as follows:

a. Paragraph 11 of the Side Letter contains the following language regarding the intent of the parties to prevent unrestricted disclosure of UNIX:

You [IBM] recognize the proprietary nature of SOFTWARE PRODUCTS and the need to protect SOFTWARE PRODUCTS from unrestricted disclosure.

b. IBM is prohibited under §7.10 of the Software Agreement from transferring or disposing of UNIX in a way that destroys its economic value. The applicable contract language reads as follows:

Except as provided in Section 7.06(b), nothing in this Agreement grants to Licensee the right to sell, lease or otherwise transfer or dispose of a SOFTWARE PRODUCT in whole or in part.

c. IBM has a duty of confidentiality to protect the confidentiality of our trade secrets. Side Letter ¶9 provides, in part, as follows:

LICENSEE [IBM] agrees that it shall hold SOFTWARE PRODUCTS subject to this Agreement in confidence for AT&T. LICENSEE further agrees that it shall not make any disclosure of such SOFTWARE PRODUCTS to anyone, except to employees of LICENSEE to whom such disclosure is necessary to the use for which rights are granted, LINCENSEE shall appropriately notify each employee to whom any such disclosure is made that such disclosure is made in confidence and shall be kept in confidence by such employee.

d. IBM is prohibited under Section 2.05 of the Software Agreements from using UNIX for others. The applicable language provides:

No right is granted by this Agreement for the use of SOFTWARE PRODUCTS directly for others, or for any use of SOFTWARE PRODUCTS by others.

The cumulative effect of these provisions requires IBM to protect our valuable UNIX trade secrets against unrestricted disclosure, unauthorized transfer or disposition and unauthorized use by others.

Notwithstanding these provisions, IBM has subjected our UNIX trade secrets to unrestricted disclosure, unauthorized transfer and disposition, unauthorized use, and has otherwise encouraged others in the Linux development community to do the same.

One of our remedies for such breaches (in addition to remedies at law and in equity) is specified in §6.03 of the Software Agreement (SOFT-00015), as follows:

If LICENSEE fails to fulfill one or more of its obligations under this Agreement, AT&T may, upon its election and in addition to any other remedies that it may have, at any time terminate all the rights granted by it hereunder by not less than two (2) months' written notice to LICENSEE specifying any such breach, unless within the period of such notice all breaches specified therein shall have been remedied; upon such termination LICENSEE shall immediately discontinue use of and return or destroy all copies of SOFTWARE PRODUCTS subject to this Agreement.

Section 6.03 is modified by ¶5 of the Side Letter to extend the notice period from 60 days to 100 days. This letter is notice of your material breaches of the AT&T/IBM Agreements identified above.

Pursuant to §6.03 of the Software Agreement, you are hereby put on notice to cure the above breaches within 100 days by eliminating the acts and conduct specified above. Should you fail to do so, your rights under the AT&T/IBM Agreements will be terminated as of Friday, June 13, 2003, and you will be required to immediately discontinue use of our Software Products and return or destroy all copies of software products subject to the AT&T/IBM UNIX Agreements.

Sincerely yours,


By: ____[Signature]_____
Darl McBride
President and Chief Executive Officer

cc: David Boies

  View Printable Version

Groklaw © Copyright 2003-2013 Pamela Jones.
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.
Comments are owned by the individual posters.

PJ's articles are licensed under a Creative Commons License. ( Details )